Skip to main content
Greenlight logo

By continuing, you accept our Privacy Statement.

Learning CenterReviewsTractive vs. Fi vs. Greenlight: which GPS tracker works best for pets?
Jobs for 10 year olds: girl using her phone while hugging a dog
Reviews

Tractive vs. Fi vs. Greenlight: which GPS tracker works best for pets?

Last updated 7 min readBeginner

Share

Kristin Marino headshot
Fact-checked

Hey, $mart parents 💡

Bring money lessons home with Greenlight’s $mart Parent newsletter, a quick read with impactful tips — delivered free to your inbox weekly.

Key takeaways

Choose Tractive if you want the most detailed activity and movement tracking.
Choose Fi Series 3+ if you want the longest battery life (up to 3 months) and access to Fi’s lost-dog community network for recovery.
Choose Greenlight Safe Pets for the lowest annual cost ($149 with data included), seamless integration with other Greenlight home management apps, and easy pet co-parenting through your family account.

Greenlight Safe Pets, Tractive, and Fi all put GPS tracking and location alerts in your pet’s collar, keeping you connected wherever your dog or cat roams. The difference is what comes with each.

Here’s a side-by-side look at what each includes, what they cost, and which one fits your family best.

Greenlight Safe Pets vs. Tractive vs. Fi overview

All three trackers use GPS to keep tabs on your pet’s location and alert you to escape attempts. The main differences are in tracking frequency, health features, and geographic coverage.

  • Greenlight Safe Pets prioritizes affordability and integration with other Greenlight services for simplified home management, making it the best bang for your buck.

  • Tractive focuses on activity and health monitoring with fast location updates.

  • Fi emphasizes extended battery life and community-based lost-pet recovery.

Here’s how they stack up.

Greenlight Safe Pets

Tractive Dog 6

Fi Series 3+

Device price

$79–$149

$79–$119

$129

Monthly subscription

Included

$6–$12/mo

$14.13-$16.50/mo

First-year total cost

$149

$223–$263

Based on $12/mo annual billing

$299–$327

Real-time GPS tracking

✓

✓

✓

Place alerts (geofencing)

✓

✓

✓

Escape alerts

✓

✓

✓

Movement history on map

✓

✓

✓

Activity monitoring

✕

✓

✓

Health/vitals monitoring

✕

✓

✓

Sleep tracking

✕

✓

✓

Battery life

Up to 3 weeks

Up to 14 days with Dog 6

Up to 3 months

Location update frequency

60 seconds

Every 2–3 sec live tracking; 2–60 min default tracking

60 seconds

Geographic coverage

120+ countries

175+ countries

US, Canada, Mexico

Waterproof rating

✓ Water resistant (IPX3)

✓ 100% Waterproof

✓ Waterproof (IP68/IP66K)

Lost-dog network

✕

✕

✓ Fi community

Co-pet-parent sharing

✓

✕

✕

Based on publicly available information as of November 2026.

Pros & cons

The three trackers solve different problems. Greenlight Safe Pets wins on battery life and cost, Tractive excels at health monitoring and fast updates, and Fi dominates on battery longevity and lost-dog recovery. Here’s where each one shines and where it falls short.

Greenlight Safe Pets pros & cons

Pros

Cons

✓ Up to 30-day battery life

✕ No health monitoring

✓ Lowest first-year cost ($79–$149)

✕ No lost-dog network

✓ Data subscription included in price

✕ Coverage limited to 120+ countries

Tractive pros & cons

Pros

Cons

✓ Fastest location updates

✕ Live mode drains battery faster

✓ Health monitoring with vitals tracking

✕ 2nd highest first-year cost $223–$263

✓ Coverage in 175+ countries

✕ Subscription required separately from device

Fi pros & cons

Pros

Cons

✓ Long battery life (up to 3 months)

✕ Most expensive first-year cost $308–$338

✓ Active lost-dog community network

✕ Limited to US, Canada, Mexico only

✓ LTE-enabled for real-time tracking

✕ No health or vitals monitoring

Pricing

Greenlight Safe Pets offers the lowest upfront cost, while Tractive and Fi require separate subscription fees on top of device purchases. Over time, Greenlight remains the most budget-friendly option, especially for families with multiple dogs.

Greenlight Safe Pets

Plan

Total price

Key features

6-month plan

$79

(plan included)

Real-time GPS

Place alerts and escape alerts

30-day battery

Shared access for co-pet parents

12-month plan

$149

(plan included)

Same features as 6-month plan

Tractive

Device/Plan

Price

Key features

DOG 6

$79

Fast updates (2–3 sec)

Health monitoring

Activity tracking

14-day battery

DOG 6 XL

$89

Fast updates (2–3 sec)

Health monitoring

Activity tracking

6-week battery

DOG 6 XL Adventure

$119

Fast updates (2–3 sec)

Health monitoring

Activity tracking

6-week battery

Subscription

$72–$144/yr

Required for all models

Fi Series 3+ plans

Fi plans

Price

Key features

Device

$129

LTE tracking

Lost-dog network

Activity tracking

Health insights

Up to 3-month battery

Annual subscription

$99/yr

Required for all models

Who wins?

Greenlight Safe Pets on total cost of ownership, especially for families with multiple dogs. Tractive for owners who want health and activity data without premium pricing. Fi Series 3+ for families prioritizing maximum battery life and willing to pay for it.

Location tracking and updates

How dogs are tracked is similar between the three. They all use GPS for location and cellular to communicate the location back to the phone apps. The key difference is update frequency. Tractive sends location updates every 2–3 seconds in live mode, while Greenlight and Fi update every 60 seconds. For dogs and cats that roam far or escape frequently, faster updates mean catching them sooner.

Greenlight vs Tractive & Fi location tracking

Feature

Tractive

Fi

Greenlight

GPS technology

✓ GPS + cellular

✓ GPS & LTE cellular

✓ Hybrid (GPS, WiFi, cellular)

Real-time updates

Every 2–3 sec

Every 60 sec

Every 60 sec

Works without phones nearby

✓

✓

✓

Movement history map

✓

✓

✓

Global coverage

175+ countries

US, Canada, Mexico

120+ countries

Who wins?

Tractive pulls ahead if your dog escapes frequently and you need to locate them in seconds. Fi is ideal if you live in North America and want LTE reliability without GPS dependency. Greenlight works well for everyday tracking and geofencing but isn’t built for rapid-response searches.

Geofencing and escape alerts

All three send notifications when your dog leaves a safe zone, but they work slightly differently. Tractive and Greenlight use GPS geofencing, while Fi uses a combination of GPS and WiFi connectivity. Tractive notifies within seconds, while Fi and Greenlight may take a few minutes depending on network conditions. The choice depends on how reactive your dog is and how quickly you need to know they’ve escaped.

Greenlight vs Tractive & Fi geofencing

Feature

Tractive

Fi

Greenlight

Geofencing alerts

✓

✓

✓

Escape alert speed

Within seconds

Within minutes

Within minutes

Customizable safe zones

✓

✓

✓

Multiple zones allowed

✓

✓

✓

Wi-Fi zone detection

✕

✓ (with WiFi)

✕

Who wins?

Tractive wins for owners of escape artists who need instant alerts. Fi is great for homes with strong WiFi that want a backup system. Greenlight comes out on top for everyday monitoring without the false alerts that can plague faster-updating systems.

Health and activity monitoring

This is where Tractive stands apart. It’s the only tracker that monitors health vitals, including heart rate and respiratory rate, which can alert owners to early signs of illness. Fi tracks activity and sleep but not health metrics. Greenlight focuses purely on location and doesn’t include activity or health monitoring. If your dog has a chronic condition or you want proactive health insights, this feature matters, but if you have a healthy animal who gets regular checkups, this feature probably won’t matter for the price.

Greenlight vs Tractive & Fi health and activity monitoring

Feature

Tractive

Fi

Greenlight

Activity tracking

✓

✓

✕

Sleep tracking

✓

✓

✕

Heart rate monitoring

✓

✕

✕

Respiratory monitoring

✓

✕

✕

Bark detection

✓

✕

✕

Health alerts

✓

✕

✕

Who wins?

Tractive is the clear winner if your dog has health concerns or you want detailed wellness insights. Fi offers solid activity tracking for owners who just want to monitor exercise levels. Greenlight isn’t designed for health monitoring, it’s built for location safety and family peace of mind.

The verdict

These three trackers keep your dog or cat’s location in view and alert you to escapes, but they’re built around different priorities. Tractive is engineered for owners who want comprehensive health and activity data alongside fast, accurate tracking. Fi prioritizes battery life and lost-dog recovery for owners willing to pay premium prices. is the practical choice for families seeking reliable location tracking at the lowest cost, with the added benefit of data sharing with a pet co-parent that ties into your family’s account.

  • Choose Tractive if you want the fastest location updates (every 2–3 seconds), detailed health monitoring including heart rate and respiratory alerts, and coverage in 175+ countries. Tractive is best for owners of escape artists or dogs with health conditions.

  • Choose Fi if you prioritize the longest battery life (up to three months), want a dedicated lost-dog community network, and live in the US, Canada, or Mexico. Fi is the choice for owners willing to pay more to minimize charging frequency.

  • Choose Greenlight Safe Pets if you want the most affordable tracker with data included, need multi-dog household pricing that doesn’t double per pet, and value easy family access through pet co-parent sharing. Greenlight is the practical choice for everyday location safety without premium features you may not need and don’t want to pay for.

The Greenlight Safe Family device, for Kids, Seniors, or Pets, requires the purchase of the device and a monthly data plan for connectivity. Existing Greenlight customers must be on Core, Max, Infinity or Family Shield plans to use the device. Device is not available for use with Select or Greenlight+Invest plans. See Terms for more details.

FAQs

Which dog GPS tracker is best?

It depends on your priorities and how much you want to pay. Tractive offers the fastest updates and health monitoring, Fi provides the longest battery life and lost-dog recovery, and Greenlight delivers the lowest cost with family integration.

What’s the cheapest dog GPS tracker?

Greenlight Safe Pets at $79 for a six-month plan with data included, or $149 for a 12-month plan, making it the most affordable long-term option out of the three.

Which dog tracker works internationally?

Tractive covers 175+ countries worldwide. Greenlight Safe Pets works in 120+ countries. Fi is limited to the US, Canada, and Mexico only.

How long does a dog tracker battery last?

Greenlight lasts up to 30 days. Fi lasts up to three months, and Tractive lasts up to 14 days (or six weeks for the XL model). Battery life depends on location update, frequency, and activity level.

Which pet tracker is best for escape artists?

Tractive sends alerts within seconds of escape, making it ideal for dogs or cats that bolt. Fi and Greenlight notify within minutes, which works well for routine geofencing but not rapid-response situations.


The Greenlight Safe Family device, for Kids, Seniors, or Pets, requires the purchase of the device and a monthly data plan for connectivity. Existing Greenlight customers must be on Core, Max, Infinity or Family Shield plans to use the device. Device is not available for use with Select or Greenlight+Invest plans. See Terms for more details.


Share

Teal square with the letters G and L inside of it

Join Greenlight. Love it or it's on us.†

Plans start at just $5.99/month for the whole family. Includes up to five kids.

By continuing, you accept our Privacy Statement.