How to collect rare pennies as a family
Share via
Coin collecting can be a fascinating hobby for kids, offering them a unique window into history and economics while also potentially contributing to their future financial security. One of the most accessible entry points into this world is through the humble penny. Here’s a beginner’s guide for parents looking to introduce their kids to the challenge and potential rewards of hunting for rare pennies.
A brief history of the penny
The penny has been an integral part of American currency since its inception, with the first minting occurring in 1793. This initial version was known as the Flowing Hair Chain cent, crafted under the expertise of Henry Voigt, the U.S. Mint’s chief coiner at the time. The design and composition of the penny have evolved significantly over the centuries, reflecting both the technological progress of the minting process and the cultural shifts of the periods in which they were made.
In 1909, the penny underwent a significant redesign to commemorate the 100th anniversary of Abraham Lincoln's birth. This introduced the Lincoln cent, which has continued in circulation to this day and remains a familiar aspect of everyday financial transactions. The Lincoln cent itself has seen various iterations, including the Lincoln Wheat, Lincoln Memorial, and more recent Lincoln Bicentennial designs, each marking different historical commemorations.
Each change in the penny’s design tells a unique story of America’s history, showcasing the evolution from the simple but symbolic Chain cent to the detailed depictions of one of the nation's most revered presidents. This ongoing evolution mirrors the technological advancements in minting as well as shifting cultural values, making the penny not just a tool of trade but a collector's item and a piece of historical art.
Be a financially smart family!
What makes a penny rare?
Several factors contribute to the rarity and value of pennies, each influencing collector interest and market value.
Mintage numbers
Low production figures are a primary factor making certain pennies rare. Coins like the 1909-S VDB Lincoln cent, with a mintage of just 484,000, are examples of rare coins due to their limited availability from the start.
Errors and variations
Coins with minting errors such as double dies or off-center strikes are particularly rare. For instance, the 1955 Lincoln cent with a double die error is famous for its rarity due to the doubling of design elements, making it highly sought after by collectors.
Metal composition
Changes in metal composition can also contribute to a penny’s rarity. The steel pennies of 1943, minted due to wartime metal shortages, are a good example, especially the few mistakenly struck in copper, which are now incredibly valuable.
Condition
The state of preservation significantly affects a penny's value. Coins in uncirculated condition with higher grades are more valuable, with grades ranging from 1 to 70, where 70 represents a perfect, mint-condition coin.
Demand
The market demand for a particular coin plays a crucial role in its rarity. Coins that are highly coveted by collectors, even if they are not extremely old or weren't produced in small numbers, can still be considered rare. The desirability of a coin, such as the 1909-S VDB Lincoln cent among collectors, enhances its value.
Mint marks
The mint mark on a penny, indicating where the coin was minted, can affect its rarity and value. Coins from mints that produced fewer coins in a particular year often have a higher value.
Understanding these factors helps collectors identify and evaluate rare pennies, ensuring informed decisions whether for personal collection or investment purposes. Each factor interplays to define the scarcity and potential appreciation of these numismatic pieces.
Examples of rare pennies in history
1943 copper penny: In 1943, pennies were made from steel due to wartime metal shortages, but a few were mistakenly struck in copper, making them extremely rare.
1955 double die penny: Recognizable by doubled letters and numbers due to a minting error, these pennies are highly prized.
1909-S VDB Lincoln cent: Featuring the designer's initials and a low mintage, this penny is highly sought after by collectors.
1914-D Lincoln cent: Known for its rarity due to the low number of pieces minted in Denver that year.
1922 no-D Lincoln cent: This peculiar error resulted in some pennies lacking the "D" mintmark, adding to their rarity.
1931-S Lincoln cent: Known for its extremely low mintage, making it a key date for collectors.
1969-S double die obverse Lincoln cent: Features clear doubling on Lincoln's image and the inscriptions due to a die error.
Introducing your child to coin collecting with a focus on rare pennies can be a rewarding educational experience, offering lessons in history, economics, and patience. It's a hobby that not only has the potential to grow in value over time but can also provide endless fascination and a sense of achievement as your child discovers and appreciates these tiny pieces of history. Happy hunting!
This blog post is provided "as is" and should not be relied upon as a substitute for professional advice. Some content in this post may have been created using artificial intelligence; however, every blog post is reviewed by at least two human editors.
Share via
Hey, smart parents 👋
Teach money lessons at home with Greenlight’s Smart Parent newsletter. Money tips, insights, and fun family trivia — delivered every month.
