Are sports cards a good investment? What you need to know
Once considered childhood treasures, sports cards have evolved into serious investment assets. But is this a smart way to grow your wealth? The short answer: It depends. While some rare cards have skyrocketed in value, others remain little more than nostalgic keepsakes.
In this guide, we’ll break down the pros, cons, and key strategies for sports card investing to help you decide if it's the right move for you.
The rise of sports card investing
Sports card investing has surged in popularity, driven by nostalgia, limited-edition releases, and digital marketplaces that make buying and selling easier than ever. In 2022, a 1952 Mickey Mantle rookie card sold for a record $12.6 million. This kind of headline-grabbing sale has drawn attention to the potential of sports cards as a viable investment.
But before you dive in, it’s important to understand the factors that may influence a card’s value.
Be a financially smart family!
What makes a sports card valuable?
Not all sports cards are created equal. There are several factors that help determine a card’s worth:
Player popularity: Icons like Michael Jordan, Tom Brady, and LeBron James tend to have high-value cards, but rising stars and breakout players can also experience surges in value due to collectors betting on their future potential.
Rarity and scarcity: Limited edition prints, rookie cards, and short-printed series tend to appreciate over time. The fewer copies in circulation, the higher the potential value. For example, a one-of-a-kind Patrick Mahomes card sold for $4.1 million in 2021.
Card condition: Grading services like PSA, Beckett, and SGC assess a card’s condition on a scale from 1 to 10, with mint-condition or gem-mint cards commanding premium prices. Even slight defects can significantly impact value.
Market demand: A player’s performance, retirement, or induction into the Hall of Fame can drive prices up. Significant moments, like winning a championship or breaking records, can also create spikes in demand.
Historical significance: Cards from legendary games, milestone achievements, or the early careers of Hall of Famers often become prized collectibles.
Autographs and memorabilia: Cards featuring authentic autographs, game-worn jersey patches, or unique design elements often carry added value. For example, a LeBron James rookie card, featuring both a piece of his game-worn jersey and autograph, sold for $5.2 million in 2021.
Brand and set importance: Certain brands, such as Topps, Panini, and Upper Deck, are more sought after. Specific sets like Topps Chrome Refractors, Panini Prizm, or Fleer Jordan rookie cards hold legendary status among collectors.
The pros and cons of investing in sports cards
Before you set out to invest in sports cards, it’s helpful to learn about some of the pros and cons.
Pros:
✅ High returns on rare cards: Some investors have seen six-figure profits on rare finds. Legendary cards have seen large returns in recent years. For example, a mint condition 1986 Fleer Michael Jordan rookie card appreciated in value from $8,000 to several hundred thousand dollars in the past 15 years. Additionally, rare cards of up-and-coming star players can see their rookie cards surge in price based on outstanding performances that indicate the player could develop into an all-time great. ✅ Tangible asset: Unlike stocks or crypto, you physically own a card. This provides a sense of security for investors who prefer tangible assets over digital investments that can be affected by hacking or technical failures. ✅ Diverse options: You can start with a small budget and scale up. Whether you’re purchasing a $10 prospect card or a five-figure vintage piece, there are investment opportunities at every level. ✅ Nostalgic value: Even if your investment doesn’t skyrocket, you still have a piece of sports history. Many collectors build deep emotional connections with their cards, making the investment experience more enjoyable. ✅ Potential for passive income: Some collectors rent out rare cards for exhibitions or displays at events, providing another revenue stream.
Cons:
❌ Market volatility: Prices fluctuate based on player performance, injuries, and broader economic trends. What’s hot today might be forgotten tomorrow, especially for unproven young players. ❌ Authentication and fraud risks: Fake or altered cards can cause investors to lose a lot of money, especially those new to the hobby. Third-party grading services help reduce these risks, but scams are still prevalent in the market. ❌ Storage and maintenance: Cards require proper care to maintain value. Factors like humidity, exposure to light, and improper handling can lead to cards deteriorating and losing their value. ❌ Lack of liquidity: Selling at the right price may take time. Unlike stocks, which can be sold instantly, finding a buyer for high-end sports cards can take weeks or even months. Auctions and consignment services can help, but they often take a percentage of the final sale price. ❌ Market saturation risk: The modern sports card market has seen an explosion of new releases, leading to oversupply. Not all cards will hold their value long-term, and knowing which ones to invest in requires significant research.
Tips for smart sports card investing
Keep these tips in mind before you begin your sports card investing journey.
Do your research: Study market trends, auction results, and collector communities. Join online forums, watch market fluctuations, and pay attention to emerging players and historical card values. Follow reputable card investors and stay updated on industry news.
Start small: Avoid overcommitting financially until you understand the market. Buy a few lower-cost cards to get a feel for trends before making larger investments.
Buy graded cards: PSA or Beckett grading validates a card’s authenticity and tends to provide a better barometer for its value. Unauthenticated cards carry a higher risk of being counterfeit or altered, so consider taking the extra step and making the extra investment in buying graded cards or getting your own valuable cards graded.
Diversify your collection: Invest in a mix of vintage and modern cards. Vintage cards tend to hold their value better, while modern cards offer the potential for price appreciation when they involve rising stars.
Store properly: Use protective cases and climate-controlled storage to prevent damage to cards, increasing the probability that they will maintain their long-term value.
How to sell sports cards
Once you decide to test the waters and sell some of your cards, you will need an effective plan. Here are some keys to ensure you maximize your selling opportunity:
Choose a selling platform: Popular options include eBay (for fast sales), Goldin Auctions (for high-end cards), PWCC (for consignment sales), and Facebook Marketplace or card shows (for direct sales).
Grade your cards: Having your cards professionally graded by PSA, Beckett, or SGC can increase their value and make them more attractive to buyers.
Assess your cards’ value: Use online price guides, eBay sold listings, and grading reports to determine a fair market value. Take into account price ranges and trends to get a realistic expectation.
Sell strategically: Monitoring price trends will also help you pinpoint the right time to sell. If a particular card gets popular and appears to be peaking in value, your research will help determine whether you should continue to hold or try to maximize your return. On the flip side, be patient and avoid panic selling when a card, or the overall card market, experiences a downturn.
Set a competitive price: Based on your assessment of value and timing, set a competitive price based on past sales and market demand.
Consider your selling options: Take into account the platform and its available options. For example, on eBay, you may choose to sell your card auction-style or fixed-price.
Take high-quality photos: Clear, well-lit images showcasing the front and back of the card can help attract buyers.
Write a detailed description: Include player details, card condition, year, set, and any special features such as autographs or jersey patches.
Package securely: Once you have made the sale, protect the cards with sleeves inside top loaders, or even sturdier cases, and use bubble mailers or boxes for shipping to ensure safe delivery.
Should you invest in sports cards?
If you’re a sports fan who enjoys collecting, investing in sports cards can be both fun and profitable. However, it’s not a guaranteed path to wealth. The best approach is to treat it as a combination of hobby and investment. Enjoy the process while making informed decisions.
Want to raise savvy investors? With Greenlight, kids get real-world experience under your guidance. Try Greenlight, one month, risk-free.†
This blog post is provided "as is" and should not be relied upon as a substitute for professional advice. Some content in this post may have been created using artificial intelligence; however, every blog post is reviewed by at least two human editors.
†Valid for new customers only. Subject to identity verification and minimum load requirements. Your first monthly fee will be billed to your parent wallet seven days after successful registration. To receive a refund of your first monthly fee, you must request to close your account on or before the day immediately preceding your first Monthly Billing Date. See the ‘Account’ tab of Settings by tapping the gear icon on the Greenlight app home page to confirm when your risk-free trial ends. See Terms for details.
Share via
Hey, smart parents 👋
Teach money lessons at home with Greenlight’s Smart Parent newsletter. Money tips, insights, and fun family trivia — delivered every month.
