17 creative tooth fairy ideas — besides money

The tradition of the tooth fairy has been delighting kids for generations. It’s believed to have originated from folklore across cultures, where small gifts were given to mark the loss of a child’s tooth. These days, many families continue the tradition by leaving money under the pillow, with the average monetary gift coming in at a bit more than $5. 

But why stop there? The tooth fairy’s visit is a chance to create a moment of magic your child will always remember. While cash is a common choice, there’s something special about giving a gift that feels personal and thoughtful. From creative keepsakes to imaginative surprises, these non-monetary tooth fairy ideas will help you turn a small milestone into a cherished memory.

1. A handwritten note from the tooth fairy

Nothing beats the charm of a personal note from the tooth fairy. Write a tiny letter on decorative paper or use a printable template. Mention your child’s “excellent brushing job” or the fairy’s adventures collecting teeth. For an extra magical touch, sprinkle a little glitter as fairy dust and fold it into a tiny envelope.

2. A tiny fairy door

Install a small fairy door on the wall near their bed to create a magical portal for the tooth fairy. This tiny entrance can symbolize where the fairy comes and goes, adding an enchanting touch to their room. Choose one that matches their favorite colors or themes, and sprinkle some glitter around it to make it feel like the fairy just passed through. 

3. DIY certificates

Celebrate the milestone with a personalized “Tooth Fairy Certificate.” Include your child’s name, the date, and a heartfelt message about their bravery or excellent dental care. Add some decorative touches like glitter or stickers to make it feel truly special and worthy of their achievement.

Be a financially smart family!

Be a financially smart family!

From saving for the future to understanding credit, see how families are thriving with Greenlight.

Try Greenlight today

4. Fairy-sized treasures

Leave behind miniature items like a tiny jar of glitter (fairy dust), a mini scroll with a magical message, or a small charm shaped like a star or tooth. Adding a sprinkle of glitter to the area or wrapping these items in a tiny pouch can enhance the sense of wonder, making these tokens feel even more magical.

5. A book about teeth or fairies

Books like The Night Before the Tooth Fairy or Bear’s Loose Tooth make for enchanting gifts. Reading these together not only creates special bonding time but can also reinforce the importance of dental health in a fun and engaging way.

6. Glow-in-the-dark surprises

Glow sticks or small glow-in-the-dark toys create an exciting nighttime discovery for kids to find under their pillow. Imagine the excitement as they discover these glowing treasures, which you can say were enchanted by the tooth fairy’s magic. Pair these items with a little note explaining how the fairy made them shine, adding a layer of wonder to the moment.

7. Personalized bedtime stories

Write or print a short story starring your child as the hero who helped the tooth fairy on a special mission to recover magical fairy dust or save lost treasures. Incorporate their favorite activities, animals, or hobbies to make the story even more captivating. Add illustrations or use colorful paper to make it a keepsake they can treasure forever.

8. Stickers or temporary tattoos

Kids love collecting and showing off stickers or temporary tattoos, especially when they feature whimsical, fairy-themed designs. Consider finding ones that reflect their favorite characters, hobbies, or activities to make the gift feel more personal. Pair them with a note from the tooth fairy explaining how these magical items were specially chosen for them, adding a heartwarming touch to the surprise.

9. A “tooth tracker” journal

Gift a small notebook where they can record when each tooth was lost, including the date and any fun details about the experience. Leave space for them to draw pictures or write imaginative stories about how the tooth was lost or what the tooth fairy might have done with it. Adding stickers or colorful pens to the gift can make it even more exciting.

10. Fairy footprint cutouts

Cut tiny footprints from paper or sprinkle flour near the pillow to create a magical “fairy trail.” Add glitter or use colored paper for the footprints to make them sparkle, and consider leaving a small note from the fairy explaining how she tiptoed around to find the tooth. This interactive touch brings the fairy’s visit to life, creating a magical scene your child may excitedly talk about for days.

11. Custom dental care items

Make brushing fun by gifting a colorful toothbrush, sparkly toothpaste, or a tooth-shaped timer. Add a playful twist by including a note from the tooth fairy encouraging great brushing habits. For extra excitement, pair these items with a small reward chart to track their progress and celebrate their efforts.

12. A tooth fairy wand

Craft a small wand using a wooden stick, glittery paper, and ribbons in their favorite colors. Add some sparkle with adhesive gems or glitter glue, and write a short note explaining that it’s enchanted with fairy magic. This simple but special keepsake can inspire imaginative play and become a treasured reminder of their magical tooth fairy visit.

13. A “grown-up” token

Choose a charm for a bracelet or necklace they can add to as they grow, symbolizing each tooth they lose. You can select charms that reflect their personality or interests, like stars, animals, or their favorite colors. Over time, this collection can become a beautiful keepsake of their childhood milestones.

14. Puzzles or games

Leave a small puzzle, riddle, or brain teaser tailored to your child’s interests. Choose something simple yet engaging, like a word search featuring fairy-related words or a riddle that leads them to another small surprise. Take a few moments to solve it together, turning the activity into an educational bonding experience that adds an extra layer of joy to the tooth fairy’s visit.

15. Digital fairy messages

Use apps or websites to create a short, animated video message from the tooth fairy, complete with personalized details like your child’s name or the tooth’s location. You can even add a fun storyline, like how the fairy braved a magical forest to collect their tooth. This tech-savvy option combines imagination and modern tools to bring the fairy’s visit to life in an unforgettable way.

16. Plantable seeds

Gift wildflower or herb seeds to “plant with the tooth fairy” as a symbol of growing up. Include a small pot or planting kit with instructions from the tooth fairy on how to care for the seeds. As the plants grow, they’ll serve as a living reminder of this special milestone, connecting the memory to nature and growth.

17. A “tooth fairy receipt”

Create a “receipt” that acknowledges receiving the tooth, complete with playful details. Use funny “fairy terms” like “Grade A incisor” or “10/10 for shine” and include a space for the “fairy’s” signature. You could also add a little checklist of “Tooth Quality” or “Magic Points Earned” to make it even more whimsical and memorable.

How to create an unforgettable tooth fairy experience

The magic of the tooth fairy isn’t just about what’s left behind — it’s about the entire experience. With a little planning and creativity, you can turn a simple tradition into a cherished memory for your child. Here are a few tips to elevate the excitement and create a moment they’ll remember forever:

• Set the scene: Create an enchanting atmosphere with soft lighting or fairy lights. A gentle glow can make the moment feel magical and special.

• Build anticipation: Share a bedtime story about the tooth fairy before they drift off to sleep. Stories can spark their imagination and excitement for the fairy’s visit.

• Include a lesson: Use this as an opportunity to talk about the importance of good dental health. Make the lesson fun by connecting it to the fairy’s “tooth collection” criteria, like keeping teeth clean and shiny.

Creating your own tradition

The beauty of the tooth fairy tradition lies in its flexibility — you can tailor it to fit your family’s style and values. Whether you’re adding a touch of magic with glitter, incorporating a heartfelt note, or starting a unique new tradition, the key is to make it special for your child. These moments are about more than just a lost tooth; they’re about creating joy, building memories, and celebrating milestones in a meaningful way.

Want more parenting wins? From budgeting to spending wisely, Greenlight’s family money app teaches money lessons for life. Try Greenlight today. 

This blog post is provided "as is" and should not be relied upon as a substitute for professional advice. Some content in this post may have been created using artificial intelligence; however, every blog post is reviewed by at least two human editors.