Age-appropriate consequences for not doing chores

Assigning chores is a great way to teach your kids responsibility, self-discipline, and teamwork. It can also show them how hard work can translate into money if you give your kids an allowance for doing their chores. But what many parents struggle with is figuring out age-appropriate consequences when their child doesn’t do their chores. 

Here, we spoke with three experts who explained why chores are important with recommendations for effective and age-appropriate consequences for not doing chores. 

Why chores are important for child development

Chores are not just something to keep your kids busy! In fact, assigning chores to young children helps them develop executive function (EF) skills, which are crucial for school readiness and lifelong success. “Giving young children chores helps develop self-confidence and responsibility,” says Randi Albertsen, an early childhood education specialist and owner of Innovations in Education, LLC. “It also helps children feel a sense of agency and ownership.”

Starting chores early makes it easier to enforce them later. Albertsen notes that when children grow up with clear expectations around helping at home, they are more likely to continue participating in household responsibilities as they age.

Effective consequences for not doing chores by age

Not all consequences are appropriate for all ages, so choosing the right consequences for your child’s age is important. Here’s a list by age group to get you started.

Be a financially smart family!

Be a financially smart family!

From saving for the future to understanding credit, see how families are thriving with Greenlight.

Try Greenlight today

Toddlers (ages 2 and 3): Gentle guidance and redirection

• Toy time-out. If they repeatedly refuse to put toys away, the toy gets placed in a basket and put “to rest” for a little while.

• Loss of choice. Instead of letting them choose which book to read at bedtime, the parent chooses if they didn't put their books away.

• Pausing fun activities. “We can’t go outside to play until we clean up the blocks.”

Mary Willcox Smith, parenting expert and author of the book, Small Moments, Big Impact: The MicroStep Method® for the Overwhelmed Parent, explains that toddlers are not yet developmentally ready for strict consequences. Instead, she recommends that parents “use tone of voice (e.g., a firm ‘no’) or redirection.” Redirection involves shifting the child’s focus from an undesirable behavior to a more positive one.

For toddlers, it’s a good idea for parents to participate in the chores, too, as a way to begin teaching their children how to complete basic tasks. “Parents need to begin by modeling [the behavior] and doing the chores with the child… encouraging progress over perfection helps to encourage children to keep improving their skills” explains Albertson. 

Preschoolers (ages 4 and 5): Small, immediate consequences

• Toy jail. If they refuse to clean up, the toy gets “locked up” until the next day.

• Loss of a fun privilege. No stickers on the sticker chart or no extra bedtime story if chores aren’t done.

• Immediate chore completion before fun. “You can’t color until you’ve helped clear the table.”

• Helping out a sibling. If they refuse to set the table, they might have to set it for their sibling the next night.

• Role reversal. If they won’t put their laundry in the hamper, they have to try folding one small piece to learn how much harder it is when things aren’t put away properly.

At this stage, preschoolers are starting to exert their independence, which can lead to resistance when asked to complete chores. Willcox Smith suggests that parents “offer choices (e.g. do you want to put your coat on first, or your shoes?) to avoid power struggles.” She also says that making it fun is an excellent approach for toddlers. For example, saying things like: “Let’s pick up the red toys first!”

If a child refuses to clean up, Albertsen suggests a simple consequence, like placing a toy in “time-out” for a short period and saying something like: "I can see that cleanup is hard for you today. It looks like there are too many toys to play with. I'm going to put the trains in time-out until after lunch." This method helps reinforce expectations while minimizing unnecessary conflict.

Willcox Smith also emphasizes that immediate consequences work best for pre-schoolers. “If too much time passes, kids won’t connect the behavior with the outcome,” says Willcox Smith. She also recommends keeping consequences short-term, such as removing a toy for 20 minutes rather than an entire day.

School-age kids (ages 6 to 12): Loss of privileges and extra responsibilities 

• No screen time until chores are finished. If the trash isn’t taken out, there’s no TV or tablet time.

• Adding an extra chore. If they refuse to sweep the floor, they must also wipe down the table.

• Weekend privileges tied to chores. No sleepovers, playdates, or outings unless chores are completed.

• Early bedtime. If they repeatedly ignore their responsibilities, they go to bed 30 minutes earlier.

• No allowance (if applicable). If chores are tied to money, they don’t receive their full allowance.

• Chores take priority over playdates. “Your friend can come over once your room is clean.”

To help children in this age group stay accountable, Michael Anderson, a licensed professional counselor, suggests that parents use visual tools like chore charts because they present chore responsibilities in a straightforward way. "Clear structure and follow-through help children understand the connection between their choices and consequences," Anderson says. 

When children neglect their chores, losing privileges is often an effective consequence. Anderson suggests an immediate and logical consequence. "Enforce immediate consequences like loss of privileges (e.g. reduced screen time),” he says. “When children complete their chores independently, use positive reinforcement, like verbal praise, a later bedtime, or more screen time."

Tweens and teens (ages 13 to 18): Real-world and natural consequences

• Loss of phone or WiFi access. No phone, social media, or gaming until chores are complete.

• No ride or transportation help. If they don’t do their part, parents don’t give them a ride to an event.

• Extra responsibilities. If they don’t do their assigned chores, they must also help with an additional household task.

• Withholding money for outings. No allowance or extra spending money if they don’t contribute at home.

• Natural consequences. If they don’t wash their clothes, they wear dirty clothes. If they don’t pack their lunch, they have to buy or make their own.

• Later curfew restrictions. If they don’t respect the house rules (chores included), their curfew gets moved earlier.

• When → Then approach. “When you finish mowing the lawn, then you can have the car keys.”

When kids become tweens and teens, natural consequences are often the most effective. For example, if a child refuses to clean up their mess, they may have to deal with the inconvenience of not finding their things later. If they don’t set the table, they won’t have a plate ready at dinnertime. These natural consequences help children understand the direct impact of their actions.

Anderson adds that communication and boundary-setting are both important at this stage. "Having open conversations about shared household chores is very important during these years—the key is creating clear boundaries while nurturing your parent-child relationship," he says.

Willcox Smith’s "When → Then" approach is an effective alternative to traditional punishments or threats. Instead of “Why can’t you be more responsible? You never do your chores! I’m taking your tablet for a week,” try: “When the dishwasher is unloaded, then you can have the tablet.” 

Willcox Smith says this method eliminates power struggles and mirrors real-world responsibility, but acknowledges some challenges. "The hardest part? Staying calm, letting them fail a few times, and holding the boundary when they don’t get the tablet that day," she says. 

By allowing teens to experience the direct outcomes of their actions, parents can help them develop self-discipline and accountability in a way that reflects real-world cause and effect.

Chores (and consequences!) are all about building life skills with your child. “Kids don’t need to hurt to learn,” says Willcox Smith. “They need structure and follow-through.” By using age-appropriate strategies, you can instill responsibility without conflict. And remember that consistency is key. 

If you need some chore inspiration, check out these lists of chores by age:

• Chores for 2-year-olds

• Chores for 4-year-olds

• Chores for 5-year-olds

• Chores for 6-year-olds

• Chores for 7-year-olds

• Chores for 8-year-olds

• Chores for 10-year-olds

• Chores for teens

Turn chores into $ lessons.  Assign tasks, set rewards, and teach responsibility with Greenlight’s money app for kids and teens. Try Greenlight, one month, risk-free.†

†Valid for new customers only. Subject to identity verification and minimum load requirements. Your first monthly fee will be billed to your parent wallet seven days after successful registration. To receive a refund of your first monthly fee, you must request to close your account on or before the day immediately preceding your first Monthly Billing Date. See the ‘Account’ tab of Settings by tapping the gear icon on the Greenlight app home page to confirm when your risk-free trial ends. See Terms for details.